This year’s commemoration of the tragic events of 2001 in the US overlapped with ongoing anti-racism and anti-police-brutality protests, which have at times resulted in casualties and destruction of buildings and other property.
The commemoration for lives lost in the attacks on New York City’s twin towers of the World Trade Centre and the Pentagon, on 11 September 2001, are shadowed by a controversial hashtag making waves and spreading across the American section of Twitter – #AllBuildingsMatter.
The tag is a mockery of the All Lives Matter motto, which emerged in light of riots in the US this summer, and was first brought up by comedian Michael Che in 2016. Che used it as a response to calls to “never forget” the 9/11 terror attacks, amid the lack of attention to continuing and systemic racism in the US, as a result of longterm enslavement and segregation.
“That’s why this September, I’m getting a T-shirt that says, ‘All buildings matter.’ We’ll see how that works”, Che said in 2016, proposing the act as a response to the lack of public attention toward racism in the nation.
While it is unclear if Che fulfilled his promise, four years later his motto is trending slightly below the “never forget” devoted to the victims of 9/11 attacks (rather than the buildings, as the hashtag would suggest). This fact divided twitterians, many of whom declared the hashtag to be an insipid joke promoted by BLM protesters, and so a desecration of the memory of those who died in the tragedy.
If any of you self-important childish babies tagging #AllBuildingsMatter even had a clue what happened this day 19 years ago, had seen it, had experienced it, you’d never open your mouths again. It’s not about a building, or three buildings. You’re proving the Right, right.
— Princess Bulldog (@PerfectByGrace) September 11, 2020
Some netizens wondered why the #AllBuildingsMatter is promoted by BLM protesters, since their own protests against police brutality and endemic racism in the US at times turned into riots that saw hundreds of buildings vandalised or burnt.
Hilarious part of the #AllBuildingsMatter trend is it is being tweeted by people who are burning buildings daily.
— Carmine Sabia (@CarmineSabia) September 11, 2020
So #blm says #AllBuildingsMatter but these buildings don’t matter? pic.twitter.com/7jH1DdUnK3
— Cayotie (@Cayotie_) September 12, 2020
I’m fine w/ #AllBuildingsMatter. It doesn’t diminish 9/11 or the WTC.
I wonder why those promoting the hashtag feel it is OK to burn down courthouses, police stations, stores, and condos.
Maybe they really meant #NoBuildingsMatter, which is how they really treat Blacks.
— Joel Cannon (@joelcan) September 12, 2020
BLM supporters were quick to defend the trend, claiming that African-Americans feel the same as those infuriated by the hashtag, after key motto ‘Black Lives Matter’ was co-opted to ‘All Lives Matter’ by counter-protesters.
Does this put things into context for y’all, All Lives Matter Goofies, this is how you sound! #AllBuildingsMatter #AllBuildingMatter #BlackLivesMatter #AllLivesMattter pic.twitter.com/AaShffxEmg
— Wealth Is In The Mind (@JoeLarkBack) September 12, 2020
If #AllBuildingsMatter offends you then #AllLivesMatter should too..🤷🏾♀️. pic.twitter.com/oliCdDV66H
— Ju 🍑 (@HeeyMissJudy) September 12, 2020
Some have noted that for deaths, injuries and prison populations, the 9/11 tragedy pales in comparison to the tragedy of ongoing racism in the US.
For those calling 9/11 “America’s worst tragedy,” a combined 150 million Native American and African ancestors murdered by the white supremacist violence that birthed and maintained America would like to have a word with you. #AllBuildingsMatter #NeverForget pic.twitter.com/fzVFE3sI6S
— Bishop Talbert Swan (@TalbertSwan) September 12, 2020
Several netizens said that despite being promoted by BLM supporters, the #AllBuildingsMatter hashtag undermines Black Lives Matter, not empowers it.
I’m going to say again that #AllBuildingsMatter is an obvious attempt to smear and undermine the legitimacy of #BlackLivesMatter. And there’s a ton of people falling for it on both sides of the aisle. I don’t know how, as the whole premise is REALLY stupid, but that’s the goal. pic.twitter.com/c3UsJD6Vw9
— Fiqah (@sassycrass) September 12, 2020
#AllBuildingsMatter would be a good troll if #BlackLivesMatter
was a legitimate cause. It is not. pic.twitter.com/bN536kpima
— Melissa Tate (@TheRightMelissa) September 11, 2020
Black Lives Matter protests have been rocking the US since the end of May after an African American resident of Minneapolis died at the hands of white police while in custody. Participants demand to resolve systemic racism in the country and many seek to “defund the police”. Some peaceful protests have turned violent, particularly in response to a heavily-militarized police response, resulting in casualties, vandalism, looting and arson of both government and private property.